OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
4 posters
Page 1 of 1
OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
I sent a community review request to the people over at the "The Admin Zone" Forums, and I'm waiting for them to respond to see if fans meets their review criteria.
Here's the thread
http://www.theadminzone.com/forums/showthread.php?p=423198#post423198
Here's the thread
http://www.theadminzone.com/forums/showthread.php?p=423198#post423198
Guest- Guest
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
Alright Looks good.
KTownEgghead- Administrator
- Number of posts : 5571
Location : Great Falls, Montana
Registration date : 2008-08-04
North Fantopia Government
Rank: Dear Leader
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
Oh, and tell Greg I said thanks
KTownEgghead- Administrator
- Number of posts : 5571
Location : Great Falls, Montana
Registration date : 2008-08-04
North Fantopia Government
Rank: Dear Leader
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
I thanked him.
KermitForPrez- Legend
- Number of posts : 1764
Location : Fans on Fire
Registration date : 2008-09-10
North Fantopia Government
Rank: Dear Leader�s Bodyguard
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
WAIT.
"OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED"?
FUCK YOU ALL! THIS IS MY SITE!
lawl
"OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED"?
FUCK YOU ALL! THIS IS MY SITE!
lawl
KTownEgghead- Administrator
- Number of posts : 5571
Location : Great Falls, Montana
Registration date : 2008-08-04
North Fantopia Government
Rank: Dear Leader
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
THE RESULTS!
First Impressions
Simple is the first word that comes to mind there isn't much going on and it keeps things simple and not excessive. Also there is a lack of color.
Look
Guest's Outlook: A guest has a rather frustrating. because as a guest I get a pop message that I need to join and that pushes me right away to decide. When you first land on your site, you have very little info. The home link doesn't take to the the main page but your forum. You should consider changing this link to "forum(s)". Also your portal seems to be lacking in some info. The scrolling box is ok but you might want to consider adding a static text explaining what your site is about and in general info that may be important such as a description of your board, stats, events, new members ect. In general as a guest there is not much helpful info. Some may not be willing to find the info there looking for.
Logos and Banners: Interesting banner. I can tell its music related. But its a little one note. Try adding some colors to the banner so it stands out.
Quantity of Forums: The number of forums seems to be working for you just fine. Lack of some theme names and in general very strait forward thats ok.
Advertisements: google ad sesne dosen't get in the way but dosen't seem to very targeted. I'm sure these are forced by the forum service right?
Color Scheme and Styles: Black and White and Grey. These are the only shades I see. No hints of color expect in member names. I find it to be monotone and rather boring. There needs to be more color to draw people in. Also the black and white is hard on the eyes. Text is really hard to read and rather small.
Consider adding another theme with more color.
Page and Image Sizes: No scrolling needing nothing wrong here.
Favicon, Buttons, and Other Graphics:
Favicon is fine an F in black. Other graphics are not eye catching and are just circles with black or Grey color. Consider a guitar pick as a base image for a button set.
Feel
Theme: This is a board called Fans on fire. I don't see fire in theme. I see black and white and a lack of color and theme. The skin while not bad. Simply dosen't convey the theme of the site. There needs to be more color maybe hot colors such as red,oranges, ect. To show the fire and give the skin some flair. Besides the banner I don't see much indication of the sites topic. The banner dosen't even give enough indication as it dosen't pop. It almost blends in.
Sense of Community and Participation Overview:
You have a a good number of members who post a lot and seem to very active. But you have many members with zero posts. I would recommend contacting these people to remind them their a member of your forum and see if they need help.
Postcount and Quality:
Post count is for the most part good and people seem to have no trouble posting but there again several zero posters.
It seems like posts tend to be a little shorter but that isn't necessarily bad.
Contests, Games, and Diversions:
From what I've seen there isn't games. But a pod cast seems to be on going.
Management
Points of Registration:
Customized registration notice with a few rules of the forum.
Rules, FAQ, and Privacy Policy: Standard FAQ, Rules need improvement, no mention of a rating of the forum and what type of content is allowed. Video in the rules thread makes no sense.
Quantity and Activity of Staff:
You seem to have enough staff and they are for the most part very active.
Overall Impressions
In general a good forum that lacks branding and flair. The skin just feels boring and dosen't give the impression one would want for a board like this.
I think if another more colorful skin was chosen and some attention to what a guest see was taken. also a custom button set was used. You would draw more members in.
Also rules need to be clarified as they seem vage.
Feel free to ask any questions you may have.
__________________
First Impressions
Simple is the first word that comes to mind there isn't much going on and it keeps things simple and not excessive. Also there is a lack of color.
Look
Guest's Outlook: A guest has a rather frustrating. because as a guest I get a pop message that I need to join and that pushes me right away to decide. When you first land on your site, you have very little info. The home link doesn't take to the the main page but your forum. You should consider changing this link to "forum(s)". Also your portal seems to be lacking in some info. The scrolling box is ok but you might want to consider adding a static text explaining what your site is about and in general info that may be important such as a description of your board, stats, events, new members ect. In general as a guest there is not much helpful info. Some may not be willing to find the info there looking for.
Logos and Banners: Interesting banner. I can tell its music related. But its a little one note. Try adding some colors to the banner so it stands out.
Quantity of Forums: The number of forums seems to be working for you just fine. Lack of some theme names and in general very strait forward thats ok.
Advertisements: google ad sesne dosen't get in the way but dosen't seem to very targeted. I'm sure these are forced by the forum service right?
Color Scheme and Styles: Black and White and Grey. These are the only shades I see. No hints of color expect in member names. I find it to be monotone and rather boring. There needs to be more color to draw people in. Also the black and white is hard on the eyes. Text is really hard to read and rather small.
Consider adding another theme with more color.
Page and Image Sizes: No scrolling needing nothing wrong here.
Favicon, Buttons, and Other Graphics:
Favicon is fine an F in black. Other graphics are not eye catching and are just circles with black or Grey color. Consider a guitar pick as a base image for a button set.
Feel
Theme: This is a board called Fans on fire. I don't see fire in theme. I see black and white and a lack of color and theme. The skin while not bad. Simply dosen't convey the theme of the site. There needs to be more color maybe hot colors such as red,oranges, ect. To show the fire and give the skin some flair. Besides the banner I don't see much indication of the sites topic. The banner dosen't even give enough indication as it dosen't pop. It almost blends in.
Sense of Community and Participation Overview:
You have a a good number of members who post a lot and seem to very active. But you have many members with zero posts. I would recommend contacting these people to remind them their a member of your forum and see if they need help.
Postcount and Quality:
Post count is for the most part good and people seem to have no trouble posting but there again several zero posters.
It seems like posts tend to be a little shorter but that isn't necessarily bad.
Contests, Games, and Diversions:
From what I've seen there isn't games. But a pod cast seems to be on going.
Management
Points of Registration:
Customized registration notice with a few rules of the forum.
Rules, FAQ, and Privacy Policy: Standard FAQ, Rules need improvement, no mention of a rating of the forum and what type of content is allowed. Video in the rules thread makes no sense.
Quantity and Activity of Staff:
You seem to have enough staff and they are for the most part very active.
Overall Impressions
In general a good forum that lacks branding and flair. The skin just feels boring and dosen't give the impression one would want for a board like this.
I think if another more colorful skin was chosen and some attention to what a guest see was taken. also a custom button set was used. You would draw more members in.
Also rules need to be clarified as they seem vage.
Feel free to ask any questions you may have.
__________________
Guest- Guest
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
He made a LOT of spelling errors xD
I don't find the colors bland. I find it to be very professional looking.
I don't find the colors bland. I find it to be very professional looking.
Guest- Guest
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
i think the guys a retard...
this did it: "This is a board called Fans on fire. I don't see fire in theme."
this did it: "This is a board called Fans on fire. I don't see fire in theme."
Guest- Guest
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
Is that English?Guest's Outlook: A guest has a rather frustrating. because as a guest I get a pop message that I need to join and that pushes me right away to decide.
Zpj- Noob Fretter
- Number of posts : 3339
Location : South Africa (France)
Registration date : 2008-08-16
North Fantopia Government
Rank: Sweat Shop Worker
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
Zpj wrote:Is that English?Guest's Outlook: A guest has a rather frustrating. because as a guest I get a pop message that I need to join and that pushes me right away to decide.
No it is not...
My changes are
Guest's Outlook: A guest has a rather frustrating time, because as a guest they get a pop message that says you need to join. That forces you right away to decide to join.
I like the colors too...
Guest- Guest
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
Maybe if he joined and found out what it is about he would know why we are Fans on Fire
Electro Tomato- Recognized Fretter
- Number of posts : 1225
Location : Tomato Hell
Registration date : 2009-03-23
North Fantopia Government
Rank: Sweat Shop Worker
Re: OUR FORUM IS BEING REVIEWED
Lol, he doesnt know what hes talking about,
The colors are good, although I can understand the 0 post things.. Like it said a long time ago, if the people are here for like a month without any posts, consider them leachers and ban them...
You dont HAVE to deside to register right away, you can exit out of that lol...
The colors are good, although I can understand the 0 post things.. Like it said a long time ago, if the people are here for like a month without any posts, consider them leachers and ban them...
You dont HAVE to deside to register right away, you can exit out of that lol...
Guest- Guest
Similar topics
» FOF FF is the bad forum ever
» New Forum Theme (TELL US WHAT YOU THINK!)
» Oh look, the forum just got a little more active.
» You accidentally the whole forum.
» Forum is srs bzns?
» New Forum Theme (TELL US WHAT YOU THINK!)
» Oh look, the forum just got a little more active.
» You accidentally the whole forum.
» Forum is srs bzns?
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|