Re: The Official Fretting and Playing Contest of April

by Guest 2009-04-18, 12:01

lordhardware wrote:Motorhead - bad Religion
---------------------------------

Sync 0-100
Note Placement 0-100
Song Choice 0-100

Sync.

You had the wrong BPM, it was static and the songs BPM differs slightly throughout... and you didnt even stick to the BPM you had fretted... your first note was out of sync, and the only reason i gave you points is because the song ended ROUGHLY at the same time as your notes did... At least i CAN say your improving...

So you get 10/100

Note Placement

Your use of three note chords when it was obviously a single, and the lack of distinction between the three different notes playing in that section, put your score way down. but there were problems with the note placement throughout... All but 4 of the notes in this song should have been 8th notes...

15/100

Song Choice

This song if fretted correctly could have been quite a fun song to play, the minor BPM changes made it slightly more difficult to fret upping your score by 5.

ill give this 45 of 100

Sync 10/100

Note Placement 15/100

Song Choice 45/100

45 15 10 = 70/300 divided by 3 =

FINAL SCORE 23/100

I should've submitted a different song, maybe one of my misfits charts could've been better for this competition as i switched to Tap BPM now, thanks for the review. And that is my goal for these competitons, to improve and so far i'm succeding in that

by Guest 2009-04-18, 18:54

jrdnxxhero wrote:
jrdnxxhero wrote:Name: Stratofortress
Artist: Stratovarius
Level: 8/10
Charter: Jrdnxxhero
Difficulty: Expert
Instrument: Guitar
Link: MediaFire

Ahem.

sigh..... ok Razz

by Guest 2009-04-18, 20:20

Jrdnxxhero - CRAZY ARSE SONG!
---------------------------------

Sync 0-100
Note Placement 0-100
Song Choice 0-100

Sync.

...near PERFECT... you got marked down for having the 460 section at the start instead of cutting your ogg

ill give you 90/100

Note Placement

You copied and pasted a few sections when you should have been trying new things...for the triplets sections your should have used variants like GRB or GYB as well so as to get all 5 instead of copying, which didn't make the song any less fun... but would have perfected it.

80/100

Song Choice

Fun to play! Hard, and you did well fretting it...

ill give this 80/100

Sync 90/100

Note Placement 80/100

Song Choice 80/100

80 80 90 = 250/300 divided by 3 =

FINAL SCORE 83/100

by Guest 2009-04-18, 20:23

-IN SUMMARY

1st...

Razlo7 - A Serpents Kiss
88/100

2nd...

Jrdnxxhero - Stratofortress
83/100

3rd...

Electro Tomato - Scapegoat Blues
79/100

and

Honorable Mention...

KTownEggHead - The Rising
72.5/100

by KermitForPrez 2009-04-18, 21:33

drums nao kthx

by Electro Tomato 2009-04-18, 21:50

Electro Tomato wrote:
Electro Tomato wrote:Drums:
Shackled to the Trilithon of Kutulu - Bal-Sagoth

Guitar:
Scapegoat Blues - Jimmy Herring

That basically gives it away for anyone who entered the FoF-FF competition.

*Achem*

ADD MY FCKING GUITAR SONG ALREADY!

by Guest 2009-04-18, 22:02

....sigh....

5th song getting judged naow!!!

Razz

you whiner Razz

by Guest 2009-04-18, 22:20

O_o mine wasn't in there?

It wasn't added to the first page for some reason I guess but It's on page 2. It's expert guitar.

by Guest 2009-04-18, 22:20

+Rune+ - Scapegoat Blues
---------------------------------

Sync 0-100
Note Placement 0-100
Song Choice 0-100

Sync.

...near PERFECT... you got marked down for having the 117 section at the start instead of cutting your ogg, and some notes were out of time

ill give you 87/100

Note Placement

you got marked down for your tiny tails... and the assending triplets where you missed 3 or four notes

81/100

Song Choice

A slightly boring song (imo) but you did a good job fretting it. even if it was a static BPM

ill give this 70/100

Sync 87/100

Note Placement 81/100

Song Choice 70/100

87 81 70 = 250/300 divided by 3 =

FINAL SCORE 79/100

by Guest 2009-04-18, 22:22

ANYONE ELSE?!!

by Guest 2009-04-18, 22:24

lordhardware wrote:ANYONE ELSE?!!

ME!!! check the 2nd post on page 2 Very Happy

by Guest 2009-04-18, 22:33

Razlo7 - Symphony X
---------------------------------

Sync 0-100
Note Placement 0-100
Song Choice 0-100

Sync.

I have absolutly no problems with the sync here 100

ill give you 100/100

Note Placement

you got marked down for your tiny tails... and the (RY GR Y) bit around bar 93-103 should have been (RY GR RY) but i can see why you did it how you did...

80/100

Song Choice

Great song, fun to play, had enough BPM changes to keep you on your toes

ill give this 85/100

Sync 100/100

Note Placement 80/100

Song Choice 85/100

100 80 85 = 265/300 divided by 3 =

FINAL SCORE 88/100

by Guest 2009-04-18, 22:33

Razlo7 wrote:
lordhardware wrote:ANYONE ELSE?!!

ME!!! check the 2nd post on page 2

i meant apart from you...

by Guest 2009-04-18, 22:37

Oh.... my bad Very Happy

Thanks for the review!! And I did the RY - GR - then a single Y so it could be played as a slide... seemed more realistic that way.

by Guest 2009-04-18, 22:41

Razlo7 wrote:Oh.... my bad

Thanks for the review!! And I did the RY - GR - then a single Y so it could be played as a slide... seemed more realistic that way.

but the notes are the same... i understand the problem with slides... i CANNOT wait for custom HO/PO paths

by **KTownEgghead** 2009-04-18, 23:13

lordhardware wrote:KTownEggHead - The Rising
---------------------------------

Sync 0-100
Note Placement 0-100
Song Choice 0-100

Sync.

For the first half of the song i REALLY thought i was about to see a perfect song from you... but the 120 BPM was wrong and you didnt really pull it back together... you did have a perfect first half though so...

ill give you 50/100

Wow. The first half was perfect, but I don't see ANY sync problems in the post bridge/solo (There were some MINOR sync problems there, but they aren't that noticeable unless you open dB).

QUESTION: Did you just play the songs, or did you open them in dB/EOF? Because I opened the same file in dB and the sync was really good. As for the 120 BPM being wrong, you can't have a "wrong" BPM so long as the notes are synced with the song and you can use a 1/8, 1/12, 1/16, and 1/24th note system.

EDIT: YOU CAPITALIZED THE H IN Egghead!!!! NO!!! Now I automatically get 10 mistake points Very Happy

by Guest 2009-04-18, 23:36

i played them and opened them in FLStudio...

they were quite off ktown...

and 120 WAS wrong... if you had sync'd the notes properly to that BPM they wouldnt have been any where NEAR beatlines

by **KTownEgghead** 2009-04-18, 23:47

BUT THEY AREN'T WAHHHHHH Very Happy

I swear they aren't. lol I know they aren't. I should make a video of the song in dB.

by Guest 2009-04-18, 23:49

...and ill make a video with beat makers in FL and you'll see they ARE off Smile

FL doesnt lie... and everyone knows feedback can put notes out.

by **KTownEgghead** 2009-04-18, 23:53

But that would mean that IT'S NOT MY FAULT! YAY! Do I get points for it not being my fault?

by Guest 2009-04-18, 23:53

no... you get minus 2 points for using feedback...

get with the times KTown... feedback is dead.

by **KTownEgghead** 2009-04-18, 23:55

WHAT?!?!?!!? GASP

Feedback isn't dead. If anything, it's more alive than ever. Puppetz uses it!

(Oh wait... February Guitar Competition... Sorry Razz

)

EDIT: Go apply for a fretter group Razz

by Guest 2009-04-19, 04:50

i did...

whos this other judge... is he active?

by Guest 2009-04-19, 12:32

KTownEgghead wrote:WHAT?!?!?!!? GASP

Feedback isn't dead. If anything, it's more alive than ever. Puppetz uses it!

AND MEH!!! Very Happy

by Guest 2009-04-19, 12:55

At the very least, half of the FOF-FF fretters use Feedback.

It's not dead.

by Sponsored content